Alex Smith Vs Peyton Manning

     The San Francisco 49ers have a long standing tradition of having elite quarterbacks. For a long time now there has been a general consensus that Alex smith would not be joining the ranks of previous 49er legends, so obviously the thought of Peyton Manning being anything but a colt gets our ears buzzing, especially that we do have some cap money to play around with. Despite being cleared to play last week by his doctors, a lot is still unknown about his injury and if he will ever be 100%. He is also 36 years old. Maybe 2-3 years of solid play assuming he remains healthy. The 49ers are almost right for Manning, a now proven playoff contender with only a few offensive positions to fill as well as being in a milder climate. Another choice would be the Miami dolphins, but I think they have too much work to do for a veteran quarterback.  It seems like they will be out of the loop a few more years. Peyton is looking for a turn-key system and I think he has that with the 49ers.  However, much like Miami both stadiums are open and not domes, which I think holds Peyton back. 

      Alex smith is only 27. Sure, up until this year he had to hide from lynch mobs, but there is not a Niner fan that can’t question whether the marriage of Harbaugh and Smith can really turn him into the Elite quarterback he is supposed to be. Alex was lights out in high school and college, like almost every professional quarterback. It’s doing well in the Pro's that is the real challenge. Is it fair to say that he did not live up to his expectations? Yes, to a degree. But it was not entirely his fault. Every coach has a different offensive scheme. Aside from the head coaching changes Alex had 7 different offensive coordinators; he was riddled with shoulder injuries early in his career and was consistently berated by fans and the local media. All of those things will take a toll on the strongest of human beings. Then comes Harbaugh, a high end former NFL quarterback and with him comes Greg Roman. In one year Alex smith went from being the anti-Christ of the bay area to a winning, playoff bound NFL quarterback. I will spare the dramatics when it comes to his heroics in the last few minutes of the New Orleans game and the fact I think he deserved comeback player of the year. What else does this guy have to prove?  He has proven he can reduce mistakes(5 interceptions), he has proven he can come back from behind(Philadelphia, Detroit, New Orleans) and has proven he can win big games(New Orleans). Had it not been for two huge mistakes we might all be celebrating the 49ers instead of the New York Giants.

     As you can see, I'm with camp Alex. I don’t want to see the 49ers who have built this championship caliber team and go the way of the Jets and sign a veteran future hall of famer for a short term deal. I want a future, not just a 1-2 year novelty. I think Smith actually having an off season and the same offensive coordinator and leadership on the part of Harbaugh will give this kid something Dan Marino never had, a Super Bowl Ring. This season is do or die for Alex.

Here are his stats, compare every other year to 2011. I don't think any player has ever improved at such a dramatic pace. Lets all be reminded he scored 40 out of 50 on the Wonderlic text. This kid knows football.

			Passing									Rushing
Season	Team		GP	Rating	Att	Comp	Pct	Yds	TD	INT		Att	Yds	TD
2005	San Francisco 49ers		9	40.8	165	84	50.9	875	1	11		30	103	0
2006	San Francisco 49ers		16	74.8	442	257	58.1	2890	16	16		44	147	2
2007	San Francisco 49ers		7	57.2	193	94	48.7	914	2	4		13	89	0
2008	San Francisco 49ers		0	0.0	0	0	0	0	0	0		0	0	0
2009	San Francisco 49ers		11	81.5	372	225	60.5	2350	18	12		24	51	0
2010	San Francisco 49ers		11	82.1	342	204	59.6	2370	14	10		18	60	0
2011	San Francisco 49ers		16	90.7	445	273	61.3	3144	17	5		52	179	2
	Totals		70	76.4	1959	1137	58.0	12,543	68	58		181	629	4